More recently, however, it has come to public attention that the university has taken a downward turn. With the dramatic and sudden resignation of its president, Sidney A. Ribeau, many worry that the university's struggles are perhaps more serious than were previously thought. Interestingly enough, since Ribeau's presidency began in August 2008, Howard began to fall from its high rankings in the lists of Best Colleges in U.S. News. In 2008, it had been consistently higher up amongst the top 100. In 2010, it fell to 96th, and now in the 2014 edition in the "National Universities" category, it has been ranked at No. 142 from being 120 in 2013. So the question is, what went wrong to make its rankings drop so drastically? While many may blame Ribeau's legislation, there are many factors which have contributed to its decline. According to Robert Morse, these changes have been accredited to lowered graduation and retention rates, fall in graduation rate performance, faculty resources, student selectivity, and academic peer assessment. It has declined in most of the major academic categories which go into consideration in university rankings. But a major issue is that since it is indeed a private university, which is the norm for historically black colleges and universities, it has a smaller endowment with fewer wealthy alumni to be making substantial donations, and many of the students do not have the financial backing to afford 4 years at a decently pricey institution that cannot offer ample financial assistance with its lack of surplus resources.
Naturally, they have made cuts in costs to be able to reduce the tuition to help bring enrollment rates back up, but according to columnist Megan McArdle, there may be other underlying issues. While her presentation is a bit shaky and not very clear to the point, she makes an interesting suggestion that the racism could be playing a role in the university's recent downfall. Obviously, historically black institutions have the long-standing tradition of fighting against racism and training their students to be able to make changes in society and inspire movements of people to fight for their beliefs. But I am struggling to see how racism could have direct effect on the financial struggles of a once very highly ranked university. If this were true, I would expect to see similar stories relating to other specific universities. But maybe that is the issue is that it is overlooked. There will always be strive to compete with other universities and remain "relevant" and prestigious, but are there ways that our society may be holding back the potentially even more so augmented success of these universities?
Sources:
http://www.usnews.com/education/blogs/college-rankings-blog/2013/10/07/why-howard-university-fell-in-the-best-colleges-rankings
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-10-04/racism-continues-to-hurt-historically-black-colleges.html
http://www.howard.edu/
http://hbcudigest.com/fear-of-an-average-howard-university/
I do not feel that it is our society that is holding back in giving donations to the school. I feel that it it is combination of things such as the retention rate and the price to go to the school must put a hole in the pocket of a out of college adult. The president of the school blaming it on racism just seems like an excuse as the times that the school started to decline happened around the time the president was replaced. To me just doesn't add up. If the school had a history of bad academics and low retention rate I could see racism being a factor as it might play a role in the lack of students that get jobs after college.
ReplyDeleteThis definitely doesn't add up to me. I don't think its inaccurate to say that this is a case of mismanagement on the part of the administration that led to a drop in the rankings. The graduates of the school aren't (or at least they shouldn't be) racist, so that wouldn't be preventing them from donating to the school. It is entirely possible, and more probable that something else is going on.
ReplyDelete